How far in advance do I need to place an order?

1 week is best, but depending on what you are ordering, we can do our best to make the magic happen in fewer days!

Is there an order minimum?

Custom cookies: 1 dozen minimum.

Holiday / seasonal cookies & kits: No minimum

What all can you design?

With our creative ideas combined - together you & I can definitely create a fun & unique design for your special day.  Let's start with a theme & your favorite colors and get the yummy cookie ideas flowing!  (Hint: Pinterest will be your BFF)

Can I place an order online?

As your custom cookie order will be super personalized for your special day, we are not taking orders online.  Please call or email us @  yummy@hollystreetbakery.com  to chat about what your would like us to create custom just for you! 

Where will I pick up my order?

Our home bakery is in a residential area in Titusville near Garden Street (406) & Singleton Ave. The physical location will be provided with your order is confirmed.

Do you ship cookies?

We are still working out the full logistics on how to safety ship our cookie creations to insure they look amazing when they arrive.  Depending on the size of your order - we can surely work something out! (Continental US only)

Is it difficult baking cookies and NOT eating them too?

OMG yes!  They are amazing!  Thankfully thats what the "whoops" cookies are for!